Today we’re going to be talking about our final theme, and that is the ethics of war and peace. We’re going to be talking about violence, about when violence is justified, and about how to justify violence. And we’re going to be drawing on the rich ethical theories that we’ve been talking about over the past few weeks.
We’re going to be using the Bagavad Gita, the very famous Indian spiritual and philosophical text, as a text to think alongside as we’re talking about this topic. By this I mean the Bagavad Gita will be a partner in our dialogue, but we won’t actually be studying it in its own right. Will be using the Bagavad Gita as a way of opening up interesting questions about war, peace, and ethics.
In this session, we’re going to begin with an introduction to the Bhagavad-Gita, and then we’re going to talk through the opening passage that you read, where Arjuna is agonising over the thought of going into battle against his relatives. And we’re going to use this as a starting point for our reflections.
Writing exercise
Go back to the text, and extract one lines that you found compelling or interesting. Write this line in the chat. Do not post any commentary or explanation.
Now choose one line from the chat (your own or somebody else’s) as a starting point for a writing exercise. We’ll take 10 minutes.
Discussion
The text begins with Arjuna facing the possibility of going into battle against his relatives. This raises questions about the psychology of the Gita.
- Is it harder to harm someone you know than a stranger? And is this a moral fact or a psychological one?
- Would it be more wrong to fight a relative in a just cause than a stranger in an unjust one?
- What kinds of moral reflection (deontological, consequentialist etc.) does Arjuna engage in throughout the text.
The Act of Killing
One thing that is interesting about the text is that it dives into the psychology of killing. The passage that is particularly interesting is this one:
- My limbs are failing me, my mouth is drying up, there are tremors all over my body, and its hairs are standing erect.
- The bow named Gandiva slips from my hand and my skin is burning. I can no longer stand up, for my mind has become dizzy.
Reflection & Discussion
- Why do we have this kind of bodily response to the thought of violence?
- Is the fact that we have this response morally significant? In other words, is it evidence that this is something morally wrong? Or is it just… a feeling?
- How does proximity (not just closeness of social relationship, but closeness of actual people) affect our moral aversion to violence?
- What are the implications of this in the present era (drone warfare, killing-at-a-distance etc.)
Homework
This has got us started on some initial questions. Let’s now dive into Krishna’s responses to Arjuna. Read these for next time!